|
|
||||||||
Laboratory of Physiology, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Campus Gasthuisberg, Leuven, Belgium
Correspondence and requests for reprints should be addressed to Jan Eggermont, M.D., Ph.D., Laboratorium voor Fysiologie, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Campus Gasthuisberg, B-3000 Leuven, Belgium. E-mail: jan.eggermont{at}med.kuleuven.ac.be
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: CFTR ion channel airway
Anion channels form a structurally heterogeneous group of channel proteins with a common functional characteristic: the formation of a transmembrane-conductive pathway for anions. Because Cl- is the most abundant permeable anion under physiologic conditions, these channels mostly mediate Cl- currents. Anion channels are subdivided according to their gating mechanism: ligand-gated channels (such as
-aminobutyric acid and glycine receptors) that open after binding of an extracellular ligand (
-aminobutyric acid and glycine, respectively), voltage-gated Cl- channels (CLC), the phosphorylation-regulated cystic fibrosis (CF) transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) channel, volume-regulated anion channels (VRACs), and Ca2+-activated Cl- channels (CaCC*). The first three types of anion channels are relatively well understood with respect to their molecular identity, channel properties, and physiologic role (for a comprehensive review of anion channels, see Reference 1). In contrast, the molecular identity of VRAC and CaCC is still unresolved and/or controversial.
CaCCs are anion-selective channels that are activated by increases in cytosolic Ca2+. CaCCs were probably first described in Xenopus oocytes almost 20 years ago (2), and they have subsequently been identified in epithelial cells, vascular endothelial cells, neurons, and smooth and cardiac muscle cells. In line with their widespread expression, CaCCs have been implicated in a variety of cellular functions such as fertilization of the oocyte, transepithelial fluid transport, repolarization and action potential duration in cardiac myocytes, olfactory transduction, and regulation of smooth muscle tone (for reviews, see References 35). This article highlights some current problems with respect to CaCC, that is, molecular identity, pharmacology, and suitability as a target for CF therapy.
| THE CACC PHENOTYPE |
|---|
|
|
|---|
CaCC has a characteristic biophysical fingerprint (5). (1) It is activated by cytosolic Ca2+ with half-maximal concentrations for activation (KCa) in the submicromolar range: 165 nM in Ehrlich ascites tumor cells (7), 283 nM in calf pulmonary artery endothelial cells (8) for currents at +100 mV, and 0.9 µM in Xenopus oocytes at +120 mV (9). (2) Anion and cation substitution experiments reveal an anion selective channel (10). The channel poorly discriminates between anions (e.g., I- > Cl-) and has an anion permeability sequence that closely resembles the Eisenman type I sequence. This indicates that the anion-binding site in the pore is weak and that anion selection is mainly governed by the ease of dehydration. (3) CaCC displays time- and voltage-dependent currents. At subsaturating Ca2+ concentrations, the current shows slow (> 100 ms) activation at positive potentials and fast deactivation at negative potentials (8, 9). As a result, the steady-state currentvoltage relationship is steeply outwardly rectifying. However, at saturating Ca2+ concentrations (> 1 µM), the currentvoltage plot becomes progressively linear (11).
Kuruma and Hartzell have carefully analyzed the voltage dependence and kinetic behavior of the endogenous CaCC in Xenopus oocytes, taking advantage of the macropatch technique (9). This study has revealed that channel activation is Ca2+ dependent but virtually voltage independent. In contrast, channel inactivation is voltage dependent with the probability of channel closure increasing upon hyperpolarization. This model accounts both for the outward rectification at intermediary Ca2+ concentrations (< 1 µM in the Xenopus oocyte system) and for the linear currentvoltage relationship at high Ca2+ concentration (> 1 µM Ca2+). Indeed, at intermediary concentrations, the Ca2+ signal is sufficiently strong to open the channel at positive potentials, whereas the voltage-dependent closing step outweighs at negative potentials. At higher Ca2+ concentrations, the Ca2+-dependent opening predominates, even at negative potentials, thereby resulting in channel opening over the entire voltage range. However, other kinetic models have been proposed in which channel opening depends on both Ca2+ binding and voltage (12).
The Ca2+-dependent step is still incompletely understood at the molecular level. Some authors have invoked direct binding of Ca2+ to the channel, for example, in Xenopus oocytes, vascular endothelial cells, and parotid acinar cells (8, 9, 12), whereas other have provided evidence for Ca2+-dependent phosphorylation by calmodulin kinase II as the actual trigger for channel opening, for example, in T84 intestinal epithelial cells (13). In contrast, phosphorylation by calmodulin kinase II results in CaCC inactivation in tracheal smooth muscle (14). These cell-typedependent differences suggest the existence of more than one CaCC isoform and/or of different regulatory pathways.
| MOLECULAR IDENTITY OF CACC |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The CLCA Family
In spite of these problems, molecular candidates for CaCC have been forwarded over the past years, the most notable being the CLCA proteins (15, 16). The first CLCA cDNA clone was isolated in 1995 from a bovine tracheal cDNA library, which was immunoscreened with an antibody against a Ca2+-sensitive anion channel (16). Transfection of the bovine CLCA in COS-7 cells resulted in the expression of an anion-selective membrane current that was activated by the Ca2+ ionophore ionomycin (16). Further research has shown that CLCA proteins form a multigene family with several isoforms (hCLCA14 in humans, mCLCA14 in mice; note that the numbering reflects the time sequence of cloning, which differs from species to species) (17). According to a recent model (18), CLCA proteins are synthesized as 125-kD precursor proteins with five transmembrane domains (extracellular amino [NH2]-terminus, intracellular carboxyl [COOH] terminus), which is then cleaved in a 90-kD NH2-terminal fragment containing membrane spanning domains 1 to 3 and a COOH-terminal 38-kD fragment with two transmembrane domains. Heterologous expression of various CLCA isoforms have generated membrane currents that could be activated by either ionomycin or by high Ca2+ (2 mM) in the pipette solution and that were blocked by chloride channel blockers such as niflumic acid and 4,4'-di-isothiocyanostilbene-2,2'-disulfonic acid. A distinguishing feature of the CLCA currents is their sensitivity to reducing agents such as dithiothreitol (15, 16). Because these experiments were performed under Cl--selective conditions (i.e., absence of Na+ and K+ in intracellular and extracellular solutions), these data were interpreted in favor of CLCA being Ca2+-activated Cl- channels. However, this conclusion has not been universally approved because of these observations.
First, it is not clear which part of the protein is responsible for the channel properties (Figure 1). Initial biochemical experiments had indicated that the CaCC channel consisted of a multimeric 140-kD complex, which under reducing conditions fell apart in 38-kD monomers (21). Immunoscreening of a bovine trachea cDNA library with an antibody against the 38-kD monomer yielded a cDNA clone (later called bCLCA1) encoding a 100-kD peptide, which after glycosylation and proteolytic cleavage is processed in a NH2-terminal 90-kD and COOH-terminal 40-kD fragment (16). However, Ji and colleagues generated a deletion mutant from the 90-kD bCLCA1 fragment and expressed it in Xenopus oocytes (20). This fragment yielded identical currents as expressing the full-length fragment. Thus, based on immunologic and biochemical evidence, one would predict that the channel activity is located in the COOH-terminal 40-kD domain. In contrast, the mutagenesis study identifies the 90-kD subfragment as the channel protein. This discrepancy should be addressed by further studies. Moreover, although the first CLCA cDNA was cloned in 1995, we still have to wait for additional mutagenesis studies to probe the structurefunction relationship. A final problem related to the CLCA structure is the discovery of human CLCA3, which is a NH2 terminally truncated variant without any of the transmembrane domains and which appears to be secreted in the extracellular medium (19). The relationship between this secreted protein and the Cl- channel function of CLCA proteins remains to be elucidated.
|
|
To conclude, the molecular identification of CaCC is far from resolved. Although CLCA proteins are valid candidates, further data are needed before definitely establishing CLCA as Ca2+-activated Cl- channels. First, in spite of their being cloned more than 7 years ago, a detailed analysis of the biophysical fingerprint of CLCAs (ion selectivity, Ca2+ dependence, and time and voltage dependence) is still urgently needed to allow a more refined comparison with endogenous CaCC. Second, a structurefunction relationship should be worked out. A crucial experiment here is to correlate the initial observation that the channel function resides in a 40-kD fragment with the later observations that channel function resides in a larger 90-kD fragment. Third, part of the controversy could be explained by the possibility that CLCA proteins are regulators of Cl- channels rather than ion channels, as suggested by some recent experiments (23, 24). Finally, one should bear in mind that CLCA proteins can serve functions completely different from ion transport. This is suggested by the cloning of a secreted CLCA isoform (hCLCA3) incapable of transmembrane ion transport. Furthermore, several findings link CLCA to mucus production and to cell adhesion. Indeed, mCLCA3 (or gob-5) localizes to intracellular mucin granule membranes in the intestine and the lung (25). Moreover, expression of mCLCA3 promotes mucus production both in vivo (in the trachea of airway-hyperresponsive mice) and in vitro (transfection in a mucoepidermoid cell line) (26). These data suggest a role for mCLCA3 (and its human ortholog hCLCA1) in the control of mucus production and as potential therapeutic targets in diseases with mucus overproductions such as asthma. On the other hand, hCLCA2, which is expressed on the plasma membrane of pulmonary endothelial cells, mediates binding of tumor cells via a ß4 integrinhCLCA2 interaction, thereby facilitating tumor metastasis to the lung (27). Similarly, bovine CLCA2 (originally cloned as Lu-Ecam-1) is expressed in the pulmonary venous endothelium and has been shown to promote adhesion of melanoma cells (28). Thus, irrespective of their Cl- channel function, CLCA proteins are bound to generate much interest in view of their pleiotropic and clinically relevant effects.
Other Molecular Candidates for CaCC
Sun and colleagues recently showed that transient expression of human bestrophin 2, a membrane protein mutated in vitelliform macular dystrophy (Best disease), generates Ca2+-sensitive anion currents (29). An extensive homology search of the human genome has identified four bestrophin isoforms, all of which generate membrane currents in transfected HEK293 cells (30). Moreover, specific point mutations in bestrophins alter the current phenotype, suggesting that bestrophins are genuine channel components (29, 30). Furthermore, Qu and colleagues have recently examined the biophysical properties of two bestrophins cloned from Xenopus laevis oocytes. In transfected HEK293 cells, they detected Ca2+ activated Cl- currents with a KCa of 210 nM and an I- > Br- > Cl- > aspartate permeability ratio (31). Thus, bestrophins are the first cloned anion channels that are activated by physiologic Ca2+ concentrations. Based on these data, bestrophins are very promising candidates for Ca2+-activated Cl- channels, but there still remain many questions to answer. For example, do all or only some of four identified bestrophins function as Ca2+-activated Cl- channels? Are there are interacting proteins that could affect the functional properties such as Ca2+ activation and voltage dependence? Which region in the protein sequence is responsible for pore formation and gating?
It has also been reported that ClC-3 may function as a calmodulin kinase IIregulated anion channel in the plasma membrane (32). At present, it is not clear how this observation relates to the intracellular location of ClC-3 or to its presumed link to VRACs (1).
| LACK OF SPECIFIC PHARMACOLOGIC TOOLS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
| CACC AS A MOLECULAR TARGET IN CF |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A second point to bear in mind when discussing CaCC as a potential molecular target for CF is that CFTR and CaCC functionally interact. Indeed, transient expression of CFTR in a cell line without endogenous CFTR currents reduced the endogenous CaCC currents (46). The inhibition was independent of the mode of CaCC activation, as it was observed in cells dialyzed with high Ca2+ via the pipette solution and in cells stimulated with ATP as a Ca2+ mobilizing agonist. The precise mode of interaction is not understood, but the point of interaction lies downstream of the Ca2+ signal because heterologous expression of CFTR did not affect the magnitude of the Ca2+ transient in ATP-stimulated cells. The inhibition is partly activity dependent, as indicated by the observation that CaCC downregulation by CFTR is more pronounced if CFTR has been preactivated by a cAMP increasing cocktail. Conversely, Tarran and colleagues observed an upregulation of CaCC in polarized mouse tracheal epithelial cells of CF mice, although in these experiments the higher CaCC currents could partly be ascribed to an increased Ca2+ signal in CF cells (47). Taken together, these data indicate an inhibitory interaction between CFTR and CaCC with an increase in CFTR expression leading to CaCC downregulation and vice versa. Unfortunately, the lack of molecular identification hampers further experiments to nail down the precise interaction points between CFTR and CaCC.
Is CaCC Present in the Airway Epithelium?
The first question to answer when considering CaCC as a molecular target for CF is whether CaCC is present in the airway epithelium. Several experimental approaches (transepithelial short-circuit measurements or whole-cell patch clamping) point to the presence of a Ca2+-activated Cl- conductance in airway epithelial cells, in addition to the well characterized protein kinase Aactivated, CFTR-mediated Cl- conductance (48). Moreover, by selectively permeabilizing the basolateral membrane of murine tracheal epithelial cells, Gabriel and colleagues provided functional evidence for the apical location of CaCC (49).
A major shortcoming with respect to our understanding of CaCC expression in the airways is the molecular identity. The first member of the CLCA family was originally cloned from bovine trachea (16), but as discussed previously here, it remains controversial whether CLCA proteins correspond to CaCC.
Does CaCC Contribute to Airway Fluid Secretion and in Particular to ASL Volume?
A second question relates to the functional role of CaCC in the apical membrane of airway epithelium. Functional studies have indicated a Ca2+-dependent increase in Cl- secretion across airway epithelial cells. Specifically, using a murine tracheal epithelial cell line, Tarran and colleagues showed that apical application of uridine triphosphate (UTP), a Ca2+-mobilizing agonist acting on P2Y purinergic receptors, increased the short-circuit current and ASL height (47). The UTP effect was more pronounced in a CF cell line than in a wild-type cell line, again underscoring the negative interaction between CFTR and CaCC. Moreover, it was concluded that CaCC does not contribute to basal ASL homeostasis, which is predominantly determined by CFTR. In contrast, CaCC seems to be an acute regulator of Cl- secretion and ASL height and therefore integrates extracellular stimuli and ASL height. The contribution of CaCC to ASL homeostasis together with the prominent expression of CaCC in murine airway epithelium probably explains the lack of a lung phenotype in the various CF mice models (50).
Outward Rectification of CaCC: Implications for Efficient Cl- Secretion
Another point to consider is the biophysical profile of CaCC, which does not immediately suggest a role in secretion. Indeed, the steep outward rectification of CaCC implies tiny inward currents and hence minimal Cl- efflux. Thus, one might ask whether CaCC is a good target after all to bypass the cellular defect in CF. One should bear in mind that the rectification results from the opposing effects of Ca2+-dependent channel opening versus voltage-dependent channel closing (9). Outward rectification is observed at intermediary Ca2+ concentrations (opening predominating at positive potentials, closing at negative potentials), whereas at saturating Ca2+ concentrations, the voltage-independent Ca2+-dependent opening is the major event, thereby resulting in a linear currentvoltage relationship and hence significant Cl- efflux. This biophysical property is directly relevant to the problem of CF therapy. Therapeutic interventions that activate CaCC via Ca2+-mobilizing agonists should provoke (near) maximal stimulation of the airway epithelium with a micromolar Ca2+ transient, thereby ensuring significant Cl- efflux via CaCC. However, continuously exposing cells to high intracellular Ca2+ levels may trigger unwanted side effects, including apoptosis (51). A possible strategy to simultaneously activate CaCC and to avoid side effects due to a global increase in cytosolic Ca2+ would be the application of an agonist, which induces a Ca2+ signal that is spatially limited to the apical subplasma membrane zone. Mucosal administration of nucleotide agonists that act on apically located P2Y receptors may fulfill this criterion (6). Alternatively, one could look for Ca2+-independent channel openers, but the current lack of selective CaCC ligands seriously impairs this quest.
Epithelium-selective Activation of CaCC
A final point to consider is the epithelium-selective activation of CaCC in the airways. Indeed, CaCC is also expressed in airway smooth muscle, where opening of CaCC causes so-called depolarizing spontaneous transient inward currents and hence smooth muscle contraction (52). Thus, epithelium-selective activation of CaCC is required to avoid bronchoconstriction due to smooth muscle CaCC activation.
CONCLUSIONS
Although CaCC has been known for nearly two decades, it remains difficult to appreciate fully its functional role and how this channel can be exploited as a therapeutic target. The main hurdle to be taken at the moment is the molecular identification. Indeed, clarification of the genetic and protein structure will allow the development of specific molecular tools to probe CaCC structure and function at the molecular, cellular, and organ level.
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Supported by the Forton Foundation (Koning Boudewijn Stichting, Belgium).
(Received in original form June 19, 2003; accepted in final form September 5, 2003)
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
H. C. Hartzell, Z. Qu, K. Yu, Q. Xiao, and L.-T. Chien Molecular Physiology of Bestrophins: Multifunctional Membrane Proteins Linked to Best Disease and Other Retinopathies Physiol Rev, April 1, 2008; 88(2): 639 - 672. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. De La Fuente, W. Namkung, A. Mills, and A. S. Verkman Small-Molecule Screen Identifies Inhibitors of a Human Intestinal Calcium-Activated Chloride Channel Mol. Pharmacol., March 1, 2008; 73(3): 758 - 768. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Saiardi and S. Cockcroft Human ITPK1: A Reversible Inositol Phosphate Kinase/Phosphatase That Links Receptor-Dependent Phospholipase C to Ca2+-Activated Chloride Channels Sci. Signal., January 29, 2008; 1(4): pe5 - pe5. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L.-T. Chien, Z.-R. Zhang, and H. C. Hartzell Single Cl- Channels Activated by Ca2+ in Drosophila S2 Cells Are Mediated By Bestrophins J. Gen. Physiol., August 28, 2006; 128(3): 247 - 259. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Gibson, A. P. Lewis, K. Affleck, A. J. Aitken, E. Meldrum, and N. Thompson hCLCA1 and mCLCA3 Are Secreted Non-integral Membrane Proteins and Therefore Are Not Ion Channels J. Biol. Chem., July 22, 2005; 280(29): 27205 - 27212. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |