|
|
||||||||
Cystic Fibrosis/Pulmonary Research and Treatment Center, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, North Carolina
Correspondence and requests for reprints should be addressed to Richard C. Boucher, M.D., University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Cystic Fibrosis/Pulmonary Research & Treatment Center, CB# 7248, 7011 Thurston Bowles, Chapel Hill, NC 27599-7248. E-mail: rboucher{at}med.unc.edu
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: mucin epithelial sodium channel airway surface liquid
Chronic bronchitis (CB) has been defined clinically as the presence of chronic cough and sputum production for 2 months in two consecutive years. The prevalence of CB in the United States is high, with in excess of 1215 million Americans suffering from this syndrome. A general paradigm to describe the pathogenesis of genetic forms of CB, for example, cystic fibrosis and primary ciliary dyskinesia, has been emerging. This paradigm focuses on the sequence of mucus obstruction, inflammation, and ultimately infection. The focus of this review is on the pathophysiology of mucus adhesion and airway obstruction and its possible contribution to the pathogenesis of acquired forms of CB, for example, cigarette smoke-induced CB.
| MECHANISMS THAT LEAD TO FAILURE OF NORMAL MUCUS CLEARANCE |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Evidence for the notion that an imbalance of mucin and volume (salt and water) on airway surfaces leads to mucus stasis and obstruction has been slow to emerge because of difficulties in studying the morphology and function of the thin (less than 50 µm) ASL layer found in vivo. However, with the advent of the airliquid interface, a well-differentiated culture system that exhibits not only the typical morphology of airway epithelia in vivo but also the ion and water transport, mucin secretion, and surface mucus transport properties of native epithelia, detailed studies have become feasible (2). In brief, this model system has allowed quantitative studies to be performed that allow the relationships between the mucin-to-volume ratios (indexed as percent solids content of the ASL) and surface mucus transport to be examined. Thus, studies in which volume is added to or subtracted from the ASL by varying the osmolality of the serosal bathing compartment have shown that mucus with a percent solids content that mimicks conditions in vivo, 2.5%, was associated with a surface mucus transport rate of about 40 µm/second, a value close to that observed in large airways in vivo (3). Increasing the percent solids content, that is, increasing the mucin concentration, from 2.5 to 6% virtually abolished surface mucus transport. Morphologic correlates of this reduction in mucus transport were the disappearance of the PCL, flattening of cilia, and adhesion of mucus to the glycocalyx lining the apical cell surface. In contrast, and somewhat surprisingly, a decrease in percent solids from the normal 2.5 to 1.5% was associated with a marked acceleration of mucus transport to about 80 µm/second. The morphologic correlate of the addition of water to the ASL compartment was maintenance of the normal PCL height, that is, 7 µm, with a selective expansion of the mucus layer. This finding suggested that the mucus layer acts as a reservoir for liquid added to airway surfaces. It is not yet clear why mucus transport sped up with increased water content, with possibilities including an improvement of mucus layer viscoelastic properties and/or reduction of the viscosity of the PCL.
The imbalance between mucin and water, measured as an increase in percent solids, could lead to reduced mucus clearance in CB by at least two mechanisms that involve perturbations of the PCL. First, the efficacy of ciliary beat could be reduced by increased PCL viscosity. Second, the larger defect in clearance may reflect the adherence of a thickened mucus layer to airway surfaces. This adhesion event, reflecting the tethering of mucus to the cell surface, likely leads to the common clinical correlate of CB; that is, the failure to clear retained mucus through cough-dependent mechanisms. Thus, from a symptomatic point of view, it will be important to detach these adhesive mucus plaques/plugs from airway surfaces so that they can be cleared from the lung.
| WHY IS MUCUS STASIS BAD? |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Second, it is probable that mucus stasis obstructs airflow. This concept has not been explored functionally as well as it might, because of the absence of agents that clear the lung rapidly of mucus.
Finally, retained mucus constitutes a nidus for infection. Indeed, it becomes difficult to develop the syndrome of infectious CB experimentally in vivo without mucus obstruction. At least two features of mucus stasis appear to contribute to the infectious phenotype. First, mucins are typically more than 80% carbohydrate, and many respiratory pathogens have developed the capacity to secrete extracellular "mucinases" to harvest the carbohydrates contained in mucin for growth. Second, as bacteria become enmeshed in thickened (greater than 6.5% solids) mucus, they become shielded from secondary airway defenses, for example, neutrophils. Thus, studies have shown that neutrophils can easily penetrate into 1.5 and 2.5% mucus gels, but not into 6.5% mucus gels (4). Further, neutrophils can penetrate 1.5 and 2.5% mucus gels to capture live bacteria to eradicate local infection. Conversely, when the mucus is thickened (6.5% or greater), the apparent pore size in the mucin mesh is so small that neutrophils cannot penetrate the mucus gel to capture or kill bacteria. Thus, a vicious cycle is set up whereby frustrated neutrophils release elastase and other extracellular killing factors that promote intraairway inflammation, further mucin secretion, and, ultimately, destruction of airway walls.
| ETIOLOGIES OF BRONCHITIC SYNDROME |
|---|
|
|
|---|
It is perhaps CF that is the most intensively studied form of CB. Although there has been debate in the literature, it appears that cystic fibrosis is a form of CB in which the imbalance between mucin and volume reflects a primary volume defect (see Figure 2). Thus, there are in CF combined defects in regulation of Na+ transport rates and the initiation of Cl secretion that lead to a failure to regulate ASL/PCL volume adequately on airway surfaces. Thus, early in the course of the disease, the imbalance between mucin and volume reflects a normal rate of mucin secretion into a diminished volume of ASL. Later in the course of the disease, with persistent inflammation and infection, mucin secretion is increased, which further exacerbates the imbalance between mucin and volume. It is likely that the severity of this mucinvolume imbalance is a prime determinant of the severity of cystic fibrosis airway disease.
|
Much less effort has been devoted to elucidating the pathogenesis of the mucus transport defects in cigarette smoking-induced CB. There have been reports that cigarette smoke extracts can reduce the capacity of canine airway epithelia to secrete Cl ions, suggesting that there may be defects in volume on airway surfaces (5). However, studies of freshly excised human bronchi from cigarette smokers suggest that there are relatively few tonic effects on electrolyte transport properties (Table 1 [6]). Thus, whereas it is possible that there may be subtle defects in ASL volume, these data would argue for increased mucin relative to volume as the initiating event (Figure 3). This notion is consistent with the morphologic correlates of CB, which demonstrates pronounced goblet cell hyperplasia. In vitro studies have suggested that a five- to sixfold increase in mucin secretion could be sufficient, in the face of normal electrolyte/volume transport, to increase percent solids to a level at which mucus transport may cease. This hypothesis rests on the notion that mucins are secreted into ASL "dry," that is, mucin-secreting cells selectively release mucins without associated salt and water. Although no direct studies have tested this notion, the concept is consistent with the segregation of ion transport elements, for example, the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator, to ciliated cells, and the imaging studies that support the concept that mucins "swell," that is, hydrate themselves, as they enter the extracellular environment (7, 8).
|
|
It is important to note that the inflammation that is a hallmark of cigarette smoke-induced CB and infection likely would serve to exacerbate the problem of mucus adhesion and plugging. For example, serum proteins that leak into the lumen in response to inflammation may interact with mucins and increase their adhesive properties. Similarly, the DNA associated with neutrophil influx in response to inflammation and infection would also have an adverse impact on mucus adhesive properties.
| HOW CAN WE TREAT THE MUCUS STASIS COMPONENT OF CB? |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Reduction of Mucin Secretion
Certainly, in cigarette smoking-induced CB, and in the later stages of cystic fibrosis, it may make sense to reduce the rate of mucin secretion into airways to "thin" mucus, that is, to restore the balance between mucin and volume. There are two ways this goal can be achieved. First, one can block the secretion of mucins from preexisting goblet cells. This goal theoretically can be achieved by blocking receptors that trigger mucin release. Currently, the most active cell surface receptor on goblet cells that triggers mucin secretion is the P2Y2 receptor, and hence P2Y2 antagonists may be a rational choice for this purpose (7). Alternatively, one may try to block the secretory process more distally, and the recognition that the MARCKS (myristoylated alanine-rich C kinase substrate) protein is critical for vesicle fusion and release suggests that indeed this protein may be a rational target for prevention of mucin secretion (12). A theoretical problem with both approaches is that as mucin synthesis persists, goblet cells may become engorged with mucin. If there are transient periods during which block is not achieved or mechanisms evolve to circumvent the block, a dangerously high rate of mucin release might occur, perhaps mimicking the excessive release that occurs in status asthmaticus.
The alternative approach is to block the formation of new goblet cells, that is, block goblet cell hyperplasia. In the broadest approach, reduction of inflammation and infection should decrease goblet cell hyperplasia. More precise targets to achieve this goal will emerge from a more complete understanding of the mechanisms that lead to goblet cell metaplasia and hyperplasia. Currently, there are several approaches to achieving this goal. For example, there are relatively nonselective agents that may block goblet cell hyperplasia via interactions with the putative human calcium-activated Cl channel hCLCA1 (13). An alternative, intriguing approach is to block the epidermal growth factor receptor pathway in airway epithelia. This approach rests on the hypothesis that the epidermal growth factor receptor can be activated by endogenous epidermal growth factor receptor-like ligands, perhaps contained in cell surface mucins, that produce goblet cell hyperplasia.
A question that persists with regard to both mechanisms, particularly with regard to cigarette smoking-induced CB, is the long-term safety consequences of decreasing mucin secretion in the presence of inhalation of large quantities of toxicants. For example, it has been suggested that mucins provide an effective barrier to inhaled toxicants by binding them to prevent their penetration into airway epithelia. The demonstration that mice lacking MUC2 in the colon exhibited a spontaneous midlife colon carcinoma phenotype suggests that there could be long-term adverse events as a result of blocking adequate mucin secretion and prevention of toxin penetration into airway epithelia (14).
Addition of Volume to Thin Mucus and Promotion of Clearance
The concept that adding volume (salt and water) to mucus increases mucus transport has been explored in vitro (see above). However, there are no practical therapeutic agents designed to test the hypothesis that a strategy to restore mucus clearance by volume addition could be effective therapeutically. There are several reasons for the failure heretofore to test this concept.
First, many of the agents that have been touted to restore mucus clearance in clinical disease phenotypes, for example, cigarette smoking-induced CB and CF, do not effectively add volume to airway secretions. As shown in Figure 4, the ability to add volume to airway secretions rests on the capacity to block the epithelial Na+ channel. Typically, blockage of the epithelial Na+ channel not only slows liquid absorption but also reverses the driving force for net ion flow to initiate Cl secretion. Currently, only two classes of agents, P2Y2 agonists (15, 16) and amiloride-like drugs (17), have the capacity to block the epithelial Na+ channel and reverse the gradients for ion transport. As shown in Figure 5, ß agonists do not inhibit epithelial Na+ channel activity, but rather, selectively activate the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator, which does not result in Cl secretion or liquid addition. Thus, ß agonists are predicted to be progressively less effective in restoring mucociliary clearance as CB becomes more severe. It is, therefore, likely that the positive effects on mucociliary clearance in early cigarette smoking-induced CB disease are mediated by increases in ciliary beat frequency, but as the disease becomes more severe and mucociliary clearance is slowed by increased mucinvolume imbalances, ß agonists are ineffective because of their failure to add volume to airway surfaces.
|
|
The amiloride class of compounds has been extensively tested in the CF form of CB (17), but not in cigarette smoking-induced CB. Amiloride was found to be effective in acute studies designed to test for acute restoration of mucus clearance in CF. However, the duration of the therapeutic effects on Na+ channels to restore mucus transport were short, about 30 minutes, and it is probable that this pharmacodynamic property led to the failure of amiloride in chronic trials in adult patients with cystic fibrosis. Subsequent in vitro studies have revealed that the short duration of action of amiloride reflected the low potency of the compound (IC50 about 1 µM on human airway surfaces), the rapid absorption of amiloride from airway surfaces, and the rapid reversibility of the channel blockade.
A fundamental question is whether therapies designed to block Na+ channels in the lung are safe. This issue was raised by studies of mouse models of Na+ channel deletion in which the phenotype was neonatal lethality due to alveolar drowning (20). However, subsequent to those studies, clinical investigations of human patients with congenital loss-of-function mutations in epithelial Na+ channel, "pseudohypoaldosteronism," revealed striking but different results (21). First, these patients exhibited a phenotype consistent with loss of transepithelial volume Na+-dependent absorption, that is, an increase in isotonic liquid on upper and lower airway surfaces. Second, these patients appeared to compensate for the absence of transepithelial volume absorption by accelerating the surface clearance of liquid from airways. Indeed, these patients had basal mucus transport rates that were the fastest observed, exceeding those of normal subjects after inhalation of ß agonists, purinoceptor agonists, or indeed, amiloride. Third, in adults, there was no disease phenotype associated with the absence of Na+ channel blockade in the lung. For example, there was no evidence of airway infection or upper airway sinusitis. Notably, there was no evidence of alveolar flooding. Consequently, it appears that long-term Na+ channel blockade may be safe and effective in promoting clearance.
These considerations have led to programs to synthesize more potent and specific Na+ channel blockers for inhalational use for therapy of CB. Compounds have now been synthesized that are 50- to 100-fold more potent than amiloride and 5- to 10-fold less absorbable. Preclinical studies involving a sheep mucociliary clearance assay have led to observations that these pharmacologic properties lead to predictable pharmacodynamic increments in mucociliary clearance efficacy in sheep. For example, compounds that exhibit potencies 50- to 100-fold greater than amiloride, and absorption rates equal to 110 times less than amiloride, accelerate mucus transport about 2-fold more than amiloride or ß agonists. Indeed, the efficacy of the newer compounds appears to approach that observed in humans with pseudohypoaldosteronism, suggesting that complete blockage can routinely accelerate mucus transport in normal subjects fourfold. Thus, these studies augur well that these agents will be, if anything, more effective in CB, where the fold restoration of mucus clearance will be enhanced because of the basal reduction of clearance rates observed in these patients (22).
Conclusions
In conclusion, it appears that a concept has emerged to describe the pathogenesis of the mucosal surface phenotype associated with CB. An imbalance between mucin and volume depletes the periciliary liquid layer from airway surfaces and creates an adherent, tacky mucus layer. When the mucus layer adheres to the cell surface, both cilia-dependent and cough-dependent clearance mechanisms are deranged. Adherent mucus itself may be irritating and ultimately will become the nidus for bacterial infection that promotes inflammation in airway walls. Pharmacologic therapies to address this imbalance can be focused on reducing the rate of mucin secretion into the airway lumen, thereby "thinning" airway secretions. Alternatively, the addition of volume (salt and water) to airway secretions may be a safer way to clear the airways of mucins and the bound toxins/bacteria that, directly or through interactions with inflammatory cells, can damage the airway wall and lead to long-term adverse health events.
(Received in original form June 19, 2003; accepted in final form August 29, 2003)
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
F508 CFTR-expressing human bronchial epithelia. Am J Physiol 2000;279:C461C479.
-ENaC-deficient mice. Nat Genet 1996;12:325328.[CrossRef][Medline]
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
Y. Nakagami, S. Favoreto Jr, G. Zhen, S.-W. Park, L. T. Nguyenvu, D. A. Kuperman, G. M. Dolganov, X. Huang, H. A. Boushey, P. C. Avila, et al. The Epithelial Anion Transporter Pendrin Is Induced by Allergy and Rhinovirus Infection, Regulates Airway Surface Liquid, and Increases Airway Reactivity and Inflammation in an Asthma Model J. Immunol., August 1, 2008; 181(3): 2203 - 2210. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
E. Daviskas, S. D. Anderson, S. Eberl, and I. H. Young Effect of increasing doses of mannitol on mucus clearance in patients with bronchiectasis Eur. Respir. J., April 1, 2008; 31(4): 765 - 772. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. A. Mall, J. R. Harkema, J. B. Trojanek, D. Treis, A. Livraghi, S. Schubert, Z. Zhou, S. M. Kreda, S. L. Tilley, E. J. Hudson, et al. Development of Chronic Bronchitis and Emphysema in {beta}-Epithelial Na+ Channel-Overexpressing Mice Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med., April 1, 2008; 177(7): 730 - 742. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. Yoshida and R. M. Tuder Pathobiology of Cigarette Smoke-Induced Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Physiol Rev, July 1, 2007; 87(3): 1047 - 1082. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. H. Randell, R. C. Boucher, and for the University of North Carolina Virtual Lung Effective Mucus Clearance Is Essential for Respiratory Health Am. J. Respir. Cell Mol. Biol., July 1, 2006; 35(1): 20 - 28. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
W. M. Abraham, A. J. Bourdelais, J. R. Sabater, A. Ahmed, T. A. Lee, I. Serebriakov, and D. G. Baden Airway Responses to Aerosolized Brevetoxins in an Animal Model of Asthma Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med., January 1, 2005; 171(1): 26 - 34. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |